If you get a contractor's status wrong under the off-payroll working rules (IR35) and cannot show you took reasonable care, HMRC can recover the income tax and National Insurance that should have been deducted, plus employer National Insurance, from whoever is liable. Interest runs from the date each payment was due. Penalties can add up to 30% of the tax for careless errors, 70% for deliberate ones and 100% for deliberate and concealed ones. HMRC can look back four years as standard, six where you were careless and 20 where the error was deliberate. If the liable party in the supply chain does not pay, the debt can transfer to you as the client.
Most organisations treat status decisions as an admin task until HMRC opens an enquiry. By then the cost is set by decisions made years earlier, often by line managers or suppliers. This guide sets out what non-compliance costs, who pays, how far back HMRC can go and what reduces the risk.
The rules have applied to medium and large private sector clients since April 2021 and to public authorities since April 2017.
Last updated 16th November 2026
What happens if you get the off-payroll working rules wrong?
Who is liable?
The fee-payer is liable for deducting tax and National Insurance. That is usually the party that pays the worker's intermediary, often an agency. The client becomes liable when it does not take reasonable care over the status determination, when it fails to give the worker a status determination statement, or when it pays the intermediary directly. See demonstrating reasonable care.
For what this means for finance and tax leaders, see IR35 for finance and tax directors.
What can HMRC recover?
| Cost | What it means |
|---|---|
| Unpaid tax and National Insurance | Income tax and employee National Insurance that should have been deducted, plus employer National Insurance and, where it applies, the Apprenticeship Levy |
| Offset | Since 6 April 2024, HMRC reduces the bill by tax and National Insurance the worker and their company have already paid on the same income. Employer National Insurance is not reduced |
| Interest | Charged from the date each payment was due until it is paid, at the Bank of England base rate plus 4% |
| Penalties | Up to 30% of the tax for a careless error, 70% for a deliberate one and 100% for a deliberate and concealed one. Penalties can be reduced if you tell HMRC and co-operate |
| Debt transfer | If the fee-payer does not pay, HMRC can transfer the debt up the chain to the first agency and then to the client |
How far back can HMRC go?
- Four years as standard.
- Six years where the error was careless.
- 20 years where it was deliberate.
In practice that can mean every year since the rules applied to you. Our guide to how far back HMRC can go covers this in detail.
What does that look like in numbers?
Take one contractor on £600 a day for 220 days a year. Employer National Insurance alone is around £19,000 a year at the current 15% rate. That is before income tax and employee National Insurance (less any offset), interest and penalties. Over four years at that rate, for one role, it is around £76,000. Multiply that by every engagement with the same flawed determination and the exposure grows quickly.
Want a figure for your own contractor population? Use our misclassification risk calculator.
What does non-compliance look like in practice?
The largest published cases come from the public sector, where the rules have applied longest and departments publish their accounts.
- Post Office: a £104m off-payroll working bill. Read the £104m lesson.
- Home Office: £80.7m of exposure linked to contracted-out services. Read Home Office reveals £80.7m off-payroll working (IR35) exposure.
- Other government departments: we look at the pattern across departmental tax bills in IR35 in central government: lessons from recent departmental tax bills.
The common thread is that the contracts said one thing and the working practice said another. Labels such as "consultancy" or "statement of work" did not protect them.
What are the wider consequences?
- Management time: an HMRC enquiry means rebuilding years of records, often by hand.
- More scrutiny: a settlement can lead to closer attention in future HMRC business risk reviews.
- Reputation: public bodies publish these figures in their accounts, and the press reports them.
- Workforce disruption: blanket inside determinations or sudden changes to engagements can lose you skilled contractors.
- Supplier disputes: debt transfer and indemnity claims can sour supplier relationships.
How do you reduce the risk?
HMRC's question in any enquiry is whether you took reasonable care. These are the things that show you did.
- Know every off-payroll engagement, including those that come through suppliers and statements of work. See how to find every contractor in your organisation.
- Make an individual determination for each role, based on the actual working practice, not just the contract.
- Give every worker and the party you contract with a status determination statement with your reasons.
- Run a disagreement process that responds within 45 days.
- Review determinations when the role, the scope or the working practice changes.
- Keep the evidence in one place so you can answer an HMRC enquiry quickly.
- If you find past errors, consider a voluntary disclosure. See HMRC's updated voluntary disclosure guidance.
How CoComply helps
CoComply finds the contractors across your organisation, classifies each engagement, issues status determination statements and keeps a defensible record of every decision. When HMRC asks, you can show your reasoning, not rebuild it.
Be certain.
Next step: Check your risk exposure with our misclassification risk calculator.
Frequently Asked Questions
What happens if you do not comply with IR35? HMRC can recover the unpaid income tax and National Insurance, plus employer National Insurance, from whoever is liable. Interest and penalties can be added, and the debt can transfer up the supply chain to the client.
Who pays if a contractor's status is wrong? The fee-payer, usually the party paying the worker's company. The client is liable if it did not take reasonable care, did not issue a status determination statement or pays the worker's company directly.
What are the penalties for getting IR35 wrong? Up to 30% of the tax for a careless error, 70% for a deliberate one and 100% for a deliberate and concealed one. Penalties can be reduced if you tell HMRC and co-operate.
How far back can HMRC go on IR35? Four years as standard, six years for careless errors and 20 years for deliberate ones.
Does HMRC take account of tax the contractor already paid? Yes. Since 6 April 2024, HMRC offsets tax and National Insurance the worker and their company already paid on the same income. Employer National Insurance is not reduced.
Can using CEST protect us? Only if the information you put in reflects the actual working practice and you can show reasonable care around it. A tool result on its own is not a defence.
This article is for general information only. CoComply does not provide legal, tax or accounting advice, so we recommend speaking to a qualified adviser before making changes based on its content.


