IR35 for finance and tax directors: your exposure and how to manage it

Jun 20, 2023 · 7 min read

For finance and tax directors, the off-payroll working rules (IR35) are a tax control issue, not just an HR one. If your organisation cannot show it took reasonable care over contractor status decisions, it becomes liable for the unpaid tax and National Insurance, with interest and possibly penalties, often going back four to six years. That liability may need a provision in the accounts, can affect your HMRC risk rating, and in large companies falls within the Senior Accounting Officer's duty to maintain appropriate tax accounting arrangements. Personal liability for directors is rare, but it exists where unpaid National Insurance results from fraud or neglect.

Most organisations put IR35 with HR or procurement. The consequences land in finance: the tax bill, the provision, the conversation with HMRC and the board paper explaining what went wrong. This guide sets out where the exposure sits for finance and tax leaders, what HMRC expects, and the questions to ask before an enquiry asks them for you.

Last updated 18th November 2026

Where does off-payroll working risk sit for finance?

ExposureWhat it means for finance and tax
Tax liabilityIf you did not take reasonable care or issue a status determination statement, the unpaid income tax and National Insurance, employer National Insurance and Apprenticeship Levy become yours, less any tax the worker already paid. See who is responsible for IR35
Interest and penaltiesInterest from the date each payment was due. Penalties of up to 30% of the unpaid tax for careless errors, more for deliberate ones. See IR35 fines and penalties
Look-backFour years as standard, six for careless errors and 20 for deliberate ones, so one weak process can build a multi-year liability
The accountsA probable liability may need a provision, and a possible one disclosure. Public bodies have recently booked provisions of £14.8m (FCDO Services) and £38.5m (Cabinet Office)
Supply chainIf a fee-payer further down the chain does not pay, HMRC can transfer the debt up to you
Your HMRC relationshipFindings can raise your risk rating and lead to closer scrutiny in future business risk reviews

How big could it be?

Take one contractor on £600 a day for 220 days a year. Employer National Insurance alone is around £19,000 a year at the current 15% rate, before income tax, employee National Insurance, interest and penalties. Multiply that by every role with the same flawed decision, over four to six years, and the number quickly reaches board level. See the consequences of not complying with IR35, or estimate your own with our misclassification risk calculator.

Are finance and tax directors personally exposed?

The tax liability sits with the organisation, not with individuals. But three things bring it closer to you personally.

The Senior Accounting Officer duty

UK companies (alone or with other UK group companies) with turnover over £200m or a balance sheet over £2bn must have a Senior Accounting Officer, usually the finance director. The SAO must take reasonable steps to make sure the company keeps appropriate tax accounting arrangements, and certify this to HMRC each year. PAYE is one of the taxes in scope, so the controls behind off-payroll working decisions are too. An SAO who fails in this duty, or does not provide an accurate certificate on time, can be charged a personal penalty of £5,000.

Personal liability for National Insurance

Where a company fails to pay National Insurance and HMRC considers the failure was due to fraud or neglect by an officer, it can issue that director a personal liability notice. This is rare and usually arises when a company cannot pay, but it means a known gap left unaddressed is not only a corporate risk.

Governance and the board

A liability running to millions, built up over years, is a governance question as much as a tax one. Boards and audit committees will ask what finance knew, when, and what it did. Recording off-payroll working on the risk register, with clear ownership and regular reporting, protects you as well as the organisation. The Cabinet Office's accounts said for five years that it applied the rules "with care" before HMRC found otherwise. See the £38.5m Cabinet Office IR35 bill.

What should finance and tax directors do?

Six questions to ask this quarter

  1. Do we know our number? How many people work for us off payroll, through which suppliers, and what do we spend on them?
  2. Who owns it? Is there one named owner for off-payroll working decisions, and do they report to finance or the board?
  3. Can we prove reasonable care? For each engagement, is there a status determination statement with reasons and evidence of how the work is actually done?
  4. Are we the fee-payer anywhere? Where we pay the worker's company directly, we carry the deduction risk.
  5. What is our exposure? If HMRC disagreed with a sample of our decisions, what would it cost, and do we need a provision?
  6. Could we answer HMRC quickly? If a check letter arrived tomorrow, how long would it take to respond?

Controls that hold up

  • One record of every off-payroll engagement, across HR, procurement and supplier channels. See how to find every contractor in your organisation.
  • Individual determinations, reviewed when roles change.
  • Off-payroll working on the risk register, with regular reporting to the audit committee.
  • Internal audit testing the controls across every route in.
  • Supplier contracts that make fee-payer responsibilities and indemnities clear.
  • A plan for errors you find: correct them and consider a voluntary disclosure.

For the evidence HMRC expects, see what reasonable care means for IR35. If you are preparing for a wider review, see HMRC Project Snowball.

How CoComply helps

CoComply gives finance and tax teams one auditable view of the external workforce: who is engaged, through which supplier, how each engagement was classified and on what evidence. It flags changes, shows your exposure and keeps the record HMRC, your auditors and your board will ask for.

Be certain.

Next step: Book a demo to see your off-payroll exposure in one place.


Frequently asked questions

Are finance directors personally liable for IR35? Not for the tax itself, which sits with the organisation. A Senior Accounting Officer can face a personal penalty for failing to keep appropriate tax accounting arrangements, and HMRC can make a director personally liable for unpaid National Insurance caused by fraud or neglect, though this is rare.

Does the Senior Accounting Officer duty cover IR35? The duty covers the company's tax accounting arrangements for a list of taxes that includes PAYE. That includes the controls behind off-payroll working decisions.

Do we need a provision for IR35 in our accounts? If a liability is probable and can be estimated, it may need a provision. If it is only possible, it may need disclosure. Speak to your auditors.

How far back can HMRC go? Four years as standard, six where the error was careless and 20 where it was deliberate.

Who should own IR35 in a large organisation? One named owner for the process, with finance, HR, procurement and hiring managers each clear on their part, and regular reporting to the audit committee.

Sources

This article is for general information only. CoComply does not provide legal, tax or accounting advice, so we recommend speaking to a qualified adviser before making changes based on its content.

Share