Reasonable care means making each status determination the way a prudent and reasonable organisation in your position would: on the facts of each engagement, by people who understand the work, with records showing how you reached the decision. HMRC judges it against your size and resources, so a large organisation with its own finance function is expected to do more than a small one. If you cannot show reasonable care, you as the client become responsible for the tax and National Insurance, even if someone else in the supply chain was the fee-payer.
Reasonable care is the test that decides who pays when a status determination is wrong. Get it right and the liability for an honest mistake stays with the fee-payer. Get it wrong and it moves to you. This guide sets out what HMRC expects, what it says does not count, and the evidence that shows you took care.
Last updated 16th November 2026
What is reasonable care under the off-payroll working rules?
Since April 2021, medium and large clients in the private sector have had to decide whether each worker engaged through an intermediary would be an employee if engaged directly. The law requires the client to take reasonable care in reaching that conclusion and to give the worker and the party it contracts with a status determination statement (SDS) with its reasons.
HMRC describes reasonable care as acting as a prudent and reasonable person would in the client's position. Three things shape what that means for you:
- Your size and resources. A multinational with a finance function is held to a higher standard than a much smaller business.
- Your workforce. A small, simple contractor population may need only a simple process, followed accurately. A large, varied one needs more structured systems.
- Your records. HMRC expects a complete and thorough determination, with records showing how you reached it.
What happens if you do not take reasonable care?
If you take reasonable care and give the worker and the party you contract with an SDS, responsibility for deducting tax and National Insurance sits with the fee-payer, even if your decision later turns out to be wrong. If you do not take reasonable care, that responsibility moves to you as the client. This applies even if another party has already made deductions based on your original determination.
The bill then includes the income tax and National Insurance due, employer National Insurance, the Apprenticeship Levy where it applies, interest and possibly penalties. See the consequences of not complying with IR35.
What does HMRC say counts as reasonable care?
HMRC's guidance gives examples on both sides. Neither list is exhaustive.
| Shows reasonable care | Does not show reasonable care |
|---|---|
| Applying employment status principles accurately and recording how you did it | Deciding every worker engaged through an intermediary is inside the rules without looking at the facts |
| Completing CEST accurately and applying the result | Putting inaccurate information into CEST |
| Involving someone who understands the work | Leaving determinations to people without the knowledge, training or support to make them |
| Taking professional advice where you need it | Ignoring relevant evidence |
| Checking determinations on existing engagements are accurate | Making one determination for a group whose work varies |
| Making a new determination when the terms or working practice change materially | Failing to revisit a determination after a material change |
| Reviewing and improving your process | Determining status when you know the terms are about to change |
| Checking the process of anyone you outsource determinations to | Outsourcing the SDS without checking the conclusion and reasons |
Can you make one determination for a group of workers?
Only where every worker in the group is engaged on the same contractual terms and works under the same terms in practice. If the work varies, each arrangement needs its own determination. A blanket inside determination sent to every contractor is one of HMRC's own examples of failing to take reasonable care.
Does using CEST prove reasonable care?
Not on its own. Completing CEST accurately and applying its result is evidence of reasonable care. Putting in information that does not reflect the actual working practice is evidence against it. See why CEST cannot always make a determination.
Can you outsource determinations?
Yes, but you stay responsible for the accuracy of the SDS. HMRC's example of a company that hands determinations to a third party without checking its work or its qualifications ends with the liability resting with the client.
How do you evidence reasonable care?
Use this checklist to test whether your process would stand up to an HMRC enquiry.
- Scope: you know every off-payroll engagement, including those that come through procurement, statements of work and suppliers. See how to find every contractor in your organisation.
- Separation: you have recorded which suppliers provide labour and which deliver a genuine contracted-out service, and why. See contracted-out services and the off-payroll working rules.
- Individual determinations: each role is assessed on its contract and its actual working practice, not grouped unless the terms are the same.
- The right people: the hiring manager or someone who understands the work is involved, and they have training and support.
- Records: you keep the evidence and reasoning behind each determination.
- SDS issued: every worker and the party you contract with gets an SDS with your reasons.
- Disagreements: you respond to every disagreement within 45 days.
- Change triggers: an extension, change of scope or change in working practice prompts a review, and a new SDS where needed.
- Periodic review: you check existing determinations and improve the process. HMRC does not set a frequency, so set one by risk and stick to it.
- Outsourced work checked: if a third party makes determinations for you, you check its conclusions and its competence.
How CoComply helps
CoComply brings every engagement into one place, makes an individual determination based on the role and its working practice, issues the SDS and keeps the reasoning on record. Changes to an engagement trigger a review, so determinations stay accurate over time. When HMRC asks how you reached a decision, you can show it.
Be certain.
Next step: Book a demo to see how CoComply evidences reasonable care across your contractor population.
Frequently asked questions
What does reasonable care mean for IR35? Making each status determination as a prudent and reasonable organisation in your position would: on the facts of each engagement, by people who understand the work, with records of how you decided. HMRC judges it against your size and resources.
What happens if we do not take reasonable care? You as the client become responsible for deducting and paying the tax and National Insurance, even if someone else in the supply chain was the fee-payer.
Is a blanket determination ever reasonable care? Only where every worker in the group is on the same contractual terms and works under the same terms in practice.
Does using CEST prove reasonable care? Not on its own. Accurate answers that reflect the actual working practice support it. Inaccurate answers count against it.
How often should we review determinations? HMRC does not set a frequency. Review whenever the contract, scope or working practice changes, and check existing determinations regularly, more often for higher-risk roles.
This article is for general information only. CoComply does not provide legal, tax or accounting advice, so we recommend speaking to a qualified adviser before making changes based on its content.


