Who is responsible for IR35? Client, agency and contractor explained

May 18, 2022 · 7 min read

Under the off-payroll rules, the client is responsible for deciding a contractor's IR35 status, unless it is a small company in the private sector. The fee-payer, often an agency, is responsible for deducting the tax. If either fails, the liability can move up the supply chain to the client.

Last updated 4th November 2026.

IR35 responsibility sits with different parties depending on who receives the work and who pays for it. Since April 2017 in the public sector, and April 2021 for medium and large private sector organisations, the burden has moved away from the contractor. Most of it now sits with the organisation that engages them. Knowing who holds which duty is the first step to getting compliance right.

Who is responsible for what under IR35?

There are up to four parties in an off-payroll engagement. Each has its own duties.

PartyWho it isWhat it is responsible for
ClientThe organisation that receives the contractor's servicesDeciding the contractor's status with reasonable care, issuing a Status Determination Statement (SDS), keeping records and responding to any disagreement within 45 days
Fee-payerThe party that pays the contractor's company. Often an agency, or the client itself if it pays directlyIf the engagement is inside IR35: deducting Income Tax and employee National Insurance, paying employer National Insurance and any Apprenticeship Levy, and reporting through RTI
Agency or other intermediaryAny business in the chain between the client and the contractorPassing the SDS down the chain and paying the next party. It becomes the fee-payer if it pays the contractor's company
Contractor's company (PSC)The contractor's own limited companyDeciding status itself only where the client is small. Otherwise it relies on the client's SDS

The client and the fee-payer can be the same organisation. If you pay a contractor's limited company directly, you are both. You decide the status and, if they are inside IR35, you deduct the tax and pay it to HMRC.

Where an agency is involved, the duties split. You remain the client and make the determination. The agency that pays the contractor's company is usually the fee-payer and handles the deductions.

The SDS must go to the right people. You must give it to the worker and to the party you contract with. That party passes it down the chain. Keep a record that it was sent.

What if the client is a small company?

Small private sector clients do not have to make IR35 determinations. The contractor's own company decides its status instead, as it did before 2021. Whether a company counts as small depends on the Companies Act size tests, and those thresholds changed in 2025. We explain what that means in IR35 small company threshold changes: what CFOs need to know.

The exemption does not apply in the public sector. Every public authority must make determinations, whatever its size.

Who is responsible when a consultancy or outsourced service is involved?

It depends on how the work is really done. If a provider delivers a genuine, fully contracted out service, it takes on the client role, provided it is a medium or large business. If the arrangement is really a supply of people working in your teams under your managers, you are still the client, whatever the contract or the supplier says.

Some agencies now describe themselves as consultancies and tell end clients that IR35 is their responsibility. We explain how to spot this in Who is responsible for IR35 when your agency calls itself a consultancy?, and the full test in Understanding contracted out services and IR35 compliance.

The same applies to consultants seconded through professional services firms. If the individual works for you, under your direction, HMRC can treat you as the client.

Who is responsible if a contractor disagrees with the determination?

The client. A contractor or the fee-payer can challenge an SDS, and the client must consider the challenge and respond within 45 days. It must either confirm the determination with reasons or issue a new one. We cover the process in How to handle an IR35 status disagreement.

What happens if a responsibility is missed?

The liability tends to move towards the client.

How do you make sure every responsibility is covered?

  • Find every contractor, including those supplied through agencies, consultancies and service contracts
  • Confirm who is the client and who is the fee-payer for each engagement
  • Make each determination based on how the work is really done, and keep the evidence
  • Send the SDS to the worker and to the party you contract with, and record that you did
  • Check the agencies and suppliers in your chain are deducting tax correctly
  • Re-check status when an engagement is extended or its scope changes
  • Have a process for handling disagreements within 45 days

We explain how to build the complete list in How to find every contractor in your organisation.

CoComply is an external workforce compliance platform. It helps large organisations classify each engagement, route it through the right process and control the risk across their supply chain.

Next step: Our external workforce governance guide sets out how to build oversight of your whole external workforce.


Frequently asked questions

Who is responsible for deciding IR35 status? The client, meaning the organisation that receives the contractor's services. The exception is a small private sector client, where the contractor's own company decides.

Is the agency or the client responsible for IR35? Both have duties. The client makes the status determination. The agency that pays the contractor's company is usually the fee-payer and deducts the tax. If the agency does not pay, HMRC can recover the tax from the client.

Who do you send a Status Determination Statement to? To the worker and to the party you contract with, such as the agency. Keep a record that you sent it.

Can a consultancy take on IR35 responsibility? Only if it provides a genuine, fully contracted out service and is a medium or large business. If it is really supplying people who work under your direction, you remain the client.

This article is for general information only. CoComply does not provide legal, tax or accounting advice, so we recommend speaking to a qualified adviser before making changes based on its content.

Sources

Share