There is no fixed "IR35 fine". When HMRC finds that off-payroll workers were wrongly treated as outside the rules, the bill has three parts: the income tax and National Insurance that should have been deducted (less any tax the worker already paid), interest from the date each payment was due, and a penalty based on how the error happened. Penalties for inaccuracies can reach 30% of the unpaid tax for careless errors, 70% for deliberate ones and 100% for deliberate and concealed ones, and they can be reduced or suspended. In most published cases the tax and interest are far larger than the penalty: Natural Resources Wales settled for £14.6m including interest, with £2.95m of penalties suspended.
"IR35 fine" is how most people search for this, but it hides the real cost. The headline figures in the news are mostly unpaid tax and interest, built up over years of status decisions. The penalty sits on top and depends on how careful you were. This guide explains each part, how HMRC sets the penalty, what reduces it, and what recent cases show.
Last updated 18th November 2026
What can HMRC charge if you get IR35 wrong?
| Part of the bill | What it is |
|---|---|
| Unpaid tax and National Insurance | The income tax and employee National Insurance that should have been deducted, plus employer National Insurance and, where it applies, the Apprenticeship Levy. Since 6 April 2024, HMRC offsets tax the worker and their company already paid on the same income |
| Interest | Late payment interest from the date each payment was due until it is paid |
| Penalty | A percentage of the unpaid tax, set by how the error happened. This is the only part that is strictly a fine |
Whoever is liable pays the bill. That is the fee-payer, unless the client did not take reasonable care or issue a status determination statement, in which case it moves to the client. See who is responsible for IR35.
If you lead finance or tax, see IR35 for finance and tax directors for your own exposure.
How are IR35 penalties calculated?
HMRC uses the standard penalties for inaccuracies. The penalty is a percentage of the unpaid tax, known as the potential lost revenue, and depends on two things: the behaviour behind the error, and whether you told HMRC before it found out.
| Behaviour | Maximum | Minimum if you told HMRC first (unprompted) | Minimum if HMRC found it (prompted) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Took reasonable care | No penalty | No penalty | No penalty |
| Careless | 30% | 0% | 15% |
| Deliberate | 70% | 20% | 35% |
| Deliberate and concealed | 100% | 30% | 50% |
Within each range, the penalty falls with the quality of your disclosure: how far you tell HMRC about the error, help it work out the amount, and give it access to records.
Can a penalty be suspended?
Yes, for careless errors. HMRC can suspend a careless penalty for up to two years if you agree conditions to improve your processes. If you meet them, the penalty is cancelled. Natural Resources Wales had £2.95m of penalties suspended for 12 months, and the Cabinet Office expects any penalty in its case to be suspended.
How far back can HMRC go?
Four years as standard, six where the error was careless and 20 where it was deliberate. See the consequences of not complying with IR35.
What do real IR35 cases cost?
The largest published cases come from the public sector, which has been responsible for status decisions since 2017 and publishes its accounts.
| Organisation | What was disclosed | Penalty |
|---|---|---|
| Cabinet Office | £38.5m including interest, recognised in its 2025-26 accounts. HMRC found it had not taken reasonable care | Up to £8.9m possible (15% to 30% of the net tax). The department expects it to be suspended |
| Natural Resources Wales | Settled at £14.6m including interest in October 2025, after a £19m payment on account in 2024. The final figure reflected the offset rule | £2.95m, suspended for 12 months subject to conditions |
| FCDO Services (Foreign Office) | £14.8m provision in its 2025-26 accounts. Still under HMRC review | Not yet known |
| HS2 | £6.2m paid to cover the full liability HMRC identified, reported in its 2023-24 accounts | None reported |
| Home Office | £80.7m of exposure linked to contracted-out services | Not yet known |
| Post Office | A £104m off-payroll working liability | See the linked post |
We look at the pattern across government departments in IR35 in central government: lessons from recent departmental tax bills.
What do these cases tell us?
- The penalty is the smaller part. Where penalties are disclosed, they are a fraction of the tax and interest, and careless penalties are often suspended.
- Reasonable care decides who pays and how much. HMRC's finding that the Cabinet Office did not take reasonable care is what made the department liable and opened it to a penalty.
- Tools are not a defence on their own. HS2 relied on HMRC's CEST tool and still faced a bill.
- The offset rule helps. Tax already paid by contractors and their companies can now reduce the bill, as it did for Natural Resources Wales.
- Private sector cases are rarely published, but the rules and penalties are the same. A business that cannot show reasonable care faces the same three-part bill.
How do you avoid or reduce an IR35 penalty?
Avoid one in the first place
- Know every off-payroll engagement, including those that come through suppliers and statements of work. See how to find every contractor in your organisation.
- Make an individual determination for each role, based on how the work is actually done.
- Issue a status determination statement with reasons, and handle disagreements within 45 days.
- Review determinations when the role, scope or working practice changes.
- Keep the evidence, so you can show reasonable care. With reasonable care there is no penalty, even if a decision turns out to be wrong.
Reduce one if you find a problem
- Tell HMRC before it asks. An unprompted disclosure of a careless error can bring the penalty down to nothing. See HMRC's updated voluntary disclosure guidance.
- Help HMRC work out the amount and give it access to your records.
- Claim the offset for tax already paid by the worker and their company.
- Fix the process, so a careless penalty can be suspended rather than paid.
How CoComply helps
CoComply finds every off-payroll engagement, makes an individual determination with its reasoning, issues the SDS and reviews it when anything changes. That is the evidence of reasonable care HMRC looks for.
Be certain.
Next step: Check your risk exposure with our misclassification risk calculator.
Frequently asked questions
How much is the fine for IR35 non-compliance? There is no fixed fine. HMRC recovers the unpaid tax and National Insurance plus interest, and can add a penalty of up to 30% of the unpaid tax for careless errors, 70% for deliberate ones and 100% for deliberate and concealed ones.
Is there a penalty if we took reasonable care but got it wrong? No inaccuracy penalty applies where you took reasonable care. Liability for the tax also stays with the fee-payer, provided you issued a status determination statement.
Can IR35 penalties be reduced? Yes. Penalties fall if you tell HMRC about the error, help it calculate the amount and give it access to records. Telling HMRC before it finds out gives the biggest reduction.
Can an IR35 penalty be suspended? Careless penalties can be suspended for up to two years if you agree conditions to improve your processes. If you meet them, the penalty is cancelled.
What is the biggest IR35 bill so far? Among published cases, the Post Office has disclosed a £104m off-payroll working liability and the Home Office £80.7m of exposure. Most of these sums are unpaid tax and interest rather than penalties.
Who pays the IR35 bill? The fee-payer, usually the party paying the worker's company. It moves to the client if the client did not take reasonable care or did not issue a status determination statement.
Sources
- HMRC Compliance Handbook: penalties for inaccuracies (CH81000)
- HMRC Employment Status Manual: reasonable care (ESM10014)
- HMRC Employment Status Manual: offset of tax already paid (ESM10037)
- Natural Resources Wales: settlement with HMRC (24 October 2025)
- Cabinet Office Annual Report and Accounts 2025-26
- FCDO Services Annual Report and Accounts 2025-26
- Computer Weekly: HS2 finalises £6.2m settlement with HMRC
This article is for general information only. CoComply does not provide legal, tax or accounting advice, so we recommend speaking to a qualified adviser before making changes based on its content.


