In November 2024 the government set out to halve central government spending on consultancy, requiring ministerial sign-off for consultancy spend over £600,000 or lasting more than nine months, and permanent secretary sign-off over £100,000 or three months. The government says it cut consultancy spend by more than £550m in 2025. On 6 November 2026 it published version 2 of the Consultancy Playbook, which tells departments to agree the off-payroll working (IR35) status of consultancy engagements up front. For public bodies, the risk is that work moves into other categories, such as contingent labour, statements of work or contracted-out services, without anyone checking whether the off-payroll working rules apply.
Cutting consultancy spend changes how departments buy external expertise, not whether they need it. When a contract is relabelled, split or moved to another route, the people doing the work often stay the same. That is where off-payroll working liabilities build up, as recent departmental tax bills show. This post covers what the controls are, what has changed since 2024 and what public bodies should check now.
Last updated 17th November 26
What are the government's consultancy controls?
The Cabinet Office announced the controls on 14 November 2024 as part of a pledge to halve consultancy spending and save over £1.2bn by 2026.
| Control | Detail |
|---|---|
| Ministerial sign-off | Consultancy spend over £600,000, or contracts lasting more than nine months |
| Permanent secretary sign-off | Consultancy spend over £100,000, or lasting more than three months |
| Savings | £550m committed for 2024-25, and £1.2bn by 2026 |
| Framework | A new Crown Commercial Service consultancy framework, cut from £5.7bn over four years to £1.7bn over two years, with a single list of suppliers |
The Procurement Act 2023 came into force on 24 February 2025, changing how public bodies run procurements more widely.
What has happened since?
| Date | Development |
|---|---|
| 2025 | The government says it cut consultancy spend by more than £550m |
| November 2025 | The National Audit Office says the government collects data on what it spends on consultants, but not on how it uses them |
| 11 March 2026 | The Public Accounts Committee casts doubt on whether halving consultancy spend in 2025-26 is an effective way to cut spending on external providers. It says estimates of consultancy spend range from about £1.36bn to £2.23bn, that departments are not complying with Cabinet Office directives, and that large contracts combining consultancy and professional services may let departments reclassify and under-report spend rather than reduce it |
| 6 November 2026 | The Government Commercial Function publishes version 2 of the Consultancy Playbook |
What does the Consultancy Playbook say about off-payroll working?
Version 2 sets out four types of extended workforce: consultancy, contingent labour (temporary staff, interims and contractors), resource augmentation and professional services. It says:
- consultancy should fill a capability gap, while contingent labour fills a capacity gap resource augmentation counts as contingent labour for workforce planning
- everyone in the extended workforce needs background checks and a decision on the right tax treatment
- the IR35 status of consultancy engagements should be agreed up front, because changing it mid-engagement can disrupt delivery and create tax liabilities for the contracting authority
- the off-payroll working rules are more likely to apply where external staff are integrated into Civil Service teams, and should be considered case by case
What do the controls mean for off-payroll working?
Public authorities have been responsible for off-payroll working determinations since April 2017. The consultancy controls add pressure that can increase that risk in three ways.
- Work moves category, the people stay. When consultancy budgets are cut, the same work can be bought as contingent labour, resource augmentation, a statement of work or a contracted-out service. The Public Accounts Committee has already warned that spend may be reclassified rather than reduced. A new label does not change whether the off-payroll working rules apply. What matters is how the work is actually done.
- Integrated teams. Consultants who sit inside Civil Service teams, take direction from civil servants and work alongside employees look more like workers supplied to the department than a service delivered by a supplier. The Playbook itself says the rules are more likely to apply in this situation.
- Status decided late. If status is not agreed before the engagement starts, it often changes mid-way, which the Playbook says can disrupt delivery and create tax liabilities.
Recent cases show what this costs. The Home Office has reported £80.7m of off-payroll working exposure linked to contracted-out services. We look at the pattern across departments in IR35 in central government: lessons from recent departmental tax bills, and at how to tell a genuine service from a supply of labour in contracted-out services and the off-payroll working rules.
What should public bodies do now?
- List every external engagement across consultancy, contingent labour, resource augmentation, professional services and statements of work, not just the ones coded as consultancy.
- For each, record whether it is a supply of labour or a genuine service where the supplier directs and controls the work.
- Make an off-payroll working determination before the engagement starts, and issue a status determination statement where the rules apply.
- Check engagements that have moved category since November 2024. If the work and the people are the same, the determination needs revisiting.
- Watch for consultants embedded in teams, managed by civil servants or doing business-as-usual work.
- Review determinations when scope, duration or team changes.
- Keep the evidence, so you can show the Public Accounts Committee, the National Audit Office or HMRC how each decision was made.
For what reasonable care looks like in practice, see what reasonable care means for IR35.
How CoComply helps
CoComply gives public bodies one view of every external engagement, whatever route it was bought through. Each engagement is classified as labour or service, given an off-payroll working determination with its reasoning, and reviewed when it changes. CoComply is available through G-Cloud 15.
Be certain.
Next step: Download our guide to reasonable care in off-payroll working for central government.
Frequently asked questions
What are the government's consultancy spend controls? Since November 2024, central government consultancy spend over £600,000 or lasting more than nine months needs ministerial sign-off, and spend over £100,000 or lasting more than three months needs permanent secretary sign-off.
Has the government cut consultancy spending? The government says it cut consultancy spend by more than £550m in 2025. The Public Accounts Committee has questioned the data behind the target and warned that spend may be reclassified rather than reduced.
What is the Consultancy Playbook? Guidance from the Government Commercial Function on buying and managing consultancy. Version 2 was published on 6 November 2026.
Do the off-payroll working rules apply to consultants? They can. Public authorities must decide case by case. The rules are more likely to apply where consultants are integrated into Civil Service teams and directed like staff.
What is the difference between consultancy and contingent labour? The Consultancy Playbook describes consultancy as advice to fill a capability gap, and contingent labour as filling a capacity gap. Resource augmentation counts as contingent labour for workforce planning.
When should a public body decide IR35 status for a consultancy engagement? Before it starts. The Consultancy Playbook says changing tax status mid-engagement can disrupt delivery and create tax liabilities for the contracting authority.
Sources
- Cabinet Office: New controls across government to curb consultancy spend (14 November 2024)
- Government Commercial Function: The Consultancy Playbook, version 2 (6 November 2026)
- National Audit Office: Government's use of external consultants (November 2025)
- Public Accounts Committee: Chancellor's pledge to cut billions in government's consultancy spending in doubt (11 March 2026) and the full report
- PublicTechnology: government response on the £550m consultancy saving (16 March 2026)


